The Improbability of Love

The Improbability of Love

A Novel

eBook - 2015
Average Rating:
Rate this:
A smart, sweeping novel--at once satirical and moving--about love, a famous lost painting, and a dark secret from the past, set in the London art world.Annie McDee, thirty-one and recovering from the end of a long-term relationship, is chef for two sinister art dealers. She's just spent her meager savings on a dusty junk-shop painting for her new, unsuitable, boyfriend. But when he doesn't show up for his birthday dinner, it becomes hers. And amazingly, the painting speaks--though only we hear "him." Shrewd, spoiled, charming, world weary, and cynical, he comments, from his unique perspective, on Annie and the modern world, but he also recounts tales of his previous owners: Louis XV, Voltaire, and Catherine the Great, among them. Once it becomes known that Annie has the painting--whose provenance involves the Nazis--she finds herself at the center of a frantic, and sometimes fiendish, scramble among dealers, collectors, and other highly interested parties, for its...
Publisher: 2015
ISBN: 9781101874158
Characteristics: 1 online resource


From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment
Mar 24, 2019

I started reading this book a year or so ago, but wasn't ready for it then. However, on giving it another try I'm absolutely smitten with the story and the people in it. Up to a point. The ending..... well, let's just say that although summing things up can be kind of nice, in this case, summing up and tying with a giant bow and a big balloon and a voice from above stating that everyone lived happily ever after (exaggeration on my part!) might have been just a bit much. It's the reason why I didn't give more stars. However, if you're interested, go ahead and google some of the artists mentioned: Watteau, Constable, Caravaggio, etc. because seeing what they produced, the types of art they painted, will make the story come even more alive for you. And, by the way, the Caravaggio she describes truly does exist, was lost for centuries, and then found in an attic and went on to be sold for an astronomical price at auction.

May 14, 2018

Food, art, love twists, family drama, history, stories of deception, addiction but in the end truth and love prevails; what a ride! love, love it!

Jan 10, 2018

Rothchild was moved as a young woman by Watteau’s portrait of Pierrot in the Louvre. The artist’s adeptness at transferring his feelings of love and loneliness into images was her inspiration for the fictional painting she called “The Improbability of Love.” This small canvas takes centre stage in her novel of the same name. With her lively satire of the art world, Hannah Rothchild shows how works of art are “humanity’s secret diary,” containing messages that are difficult to express in other ways.

Through a dizzying array of characters who either collect art, curate it, or service the needs of the wealthy, Rothchild weaves a tale of excess where money, power and status are all interrelated. She embroils these people in a complex plot involving art theft and betrayals that reaches back to Nazi Germany. Through this convoluted story, we see how the value of a particular piece can be enhanced, sometimes to unimaginable heights.

My review wouldn’t be complete without mention of Annie, the character who discovers the Watteau painting languishing in a junk shop and brings it home. Through her work as a wonderfully creative chef who services the wealthy folks that people the art world, we see food itself raised to an art form. For Annie, food is like performance art - its power lies in its transience and immediacy - and it speaks of love, memory, the past, and the future.

Whether you like mysteries, art or fine dining, there is something in this charming story for everyone.

Surprises, plot twists, bizarre characters, a painting that tells us it's own history - what's not to like. I had to read the amazing dinner scenes twice! Highly recommended. Topical, historical, character driven. Ending was not expected, but workable.

Rose in PR

Jan 27, 2017

At times incredibly beautiful writing, compelling characters and evocative imagery ... and at other times I found myself skimming through certain chapters. This book could have done with a strict editor to streamline the plot and get rid of a few superfluous characters. But, I did enjoy it and found some of the chapters (particularly those written from the painting's POV) to be very moving.

bookishdl Dec 12, 2016

Art, cooking and love are blended together with history in a book that serves up a sensational sensory experience. I could clearly imagine the painter painting and smell the food cooking. A clever novel that is highlighted by the painting declaring its thinking by soliloquy throughout the novel. I also learned a great deal about the art world and the machinations of that arena. Highly entertaining and enjoyable.

Nov 20, 2016

Broken-hearted Annie McDee, new to London, aspires to be a chef and kind heartedly buys a painting as a gift for a new friend’s birthday. When she’s stood up and tries to return the painting, her life takes an unexpected turn.

What a hoot. Rothchild has written a delightful satire of the art world, full of characters to cheer and boo. Annie’s cooking adventures are pure pleasure. Lots of twists and turns in this artful mystery. For fans of art lost and found, the Amber Room even makes an appearance.

ser_library Oct 09, 2016

I loved the prologue but after a few chapters I skimmed the book. The blurb compares it with Evelyn Waugh who would have written a much shorter book with fewer and more complex characters. For art themed mysteries try Iain Pears.

Sep 07, 2016

This is a satire about the London art world, characterized by greed, deceit and philistinism. The novel is peopled with caricatures. Although the book is easy to read and contains some interesting reflections about art, it is a little long and the ending is simply silly.

Chapel_Hill_MeeghanR Jun 26, 2016

Many, many characters, a few, brief historical tidbits, and some interesting musings about the power of art. A pretty quick read and a peak into what likely is a foreign world to most of us. A pleasant diversion with a highly improbable plot and cast.

View All Comments

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability

There are no age suitabilities for this title yet.


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Subject Headings


Find it at RPL

To Top